| 
																	
																	
																	
																 | 
																@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																# RACK VS CARDINAL DIFFERENCES | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																
  | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																This document describes the differences between VCV Rack official plugin and Cardinal.   | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																It is not possible to know all the internal details of the official plugin due to it not being open-source, | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																so more technical details are best-guesses based on its behaviour. | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																
  | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																The obvious big difference is that the official plugin is a commercial, closed-source product while Cardinal is free and open-source. | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																
  | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																Also, the official plugin works pretty much like the free standalone where you login and download modules.   | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																This is intentionally not allowed/enabled in Cardinal, as the target is to make a self-contained plugin binary. | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																Online access is also not allowed. | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																
  | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																Bellow follows a list of features comparing the official plugin to Cardinal. | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																
  | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Feature                        | VCV Rack                  | Cardinal                        | Additional notes | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																|--------------------------------|---------------------------|---------------------------------|------------------| | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Open-Source                    | No                        | Yes                             | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Free (of cost)                 | No                        | Yes                             | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Officially supported           | Yes, if you pay           | No, but you can fix it yourself | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Contains internal modules      | Core only                 | Everything is internal          | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Loads external modules         | Yes                       | No                              | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Supports commercial modules    | Yes                       | No                              | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Plugin in LV2 format           | No                        | Yes                             | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Plugin in VST2 format          | Yes                       | Yes                             | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Plugin in VST3 format          | No                        | WIP                             | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Multi-threaded engine          | Yes                       | No, uses host audio thread      | Intentional in Cardinal, for removing jitter | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Supports ARM systems           | No                        | Yes                             | This means Apple M1 too yes | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Synth plugin variant           | Yes, 16 ins, 16 outs      | Yes, 2 ins, 2 outs              | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| FX plugin variant              | Yes, 16 ins, 16 outs      | Yes, 2 ins, 2 outs              | | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Raw-CV plugin variant          | No, unsupported           | Yes, 2 audio IO + 8 CV IO       | Not possible in VST2 format | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Arbitrary parameter automation | Yes                       | No                              | Unsupported in Cardinal, tricky to do for many plugin formats at once | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Integrated plugin host         | No, Host payed separately | Yes, using Carla or Ildaeil     | Currently work-in-progress in Cardinal | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| v1 module compatibility        | No                        | No, but with less restrictions  | Modules can load resources at any point | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Online phone-home              | Yes                       | No                              | Online access is strictly forbidden in Cardinal | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Proper dark theme              | No, only room brightness  | Yes                             | CC-ND respected by leaving files intact, dark mode applied at runtime | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																| Proper Linux headless mode     | No, always requires X11   | Yes                             | CC-ND respected by leaving files intact, dark mode applied at runtime | | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																
  | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																Additionally, Cardinal contains the following built-in modules not present in the official plugin or standalone: | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																
  | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 * Aria Salvatrice modules (except Arcane related modules, due to their online requirement) | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 * Carla Plugin Host | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 * Ildaeil Host | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 * Host Parameters (24 host-exposed parameters as CV sources) | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 * Host Time (play, reset, bar, beat, tick, bar-phase and beat-phase CV sources) | 
															
														
														
													
														
															
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 | 
																 * Host CV (for the CV IO variant, allows direct CV access to/from the DAW) |